The test comes from a 2007 study in which psychologist Gerd Gigerenzer asked 160 gynecologists: A woman tests positive on a screening mammogram. What is the chance she has breast cancer?1 Gigerenzer gave them three numbers: 1% of women have breast cancer, 90% of the women who have it test positive, and 9% of the women who do not have it test positive anyway. Most of the doctors got the answer wrong by a wide margin:1
Gigerenzer then repeated the experiment with the same facts expressed as head counts: Of 1,000 women, 10 have breast cancer, and 9 of them test positive. Of the 990 women without cancer, about 89 test positive too. A woman tests positive. What is the chance she has breast cancer?1 This time, most of the doctors found the best answer:1
Gigerenzer concluded that the problem is not the doctors, but how the numbers are presented.1 Percentages have to be combined mentally. Head counts put everyone into one group, so the ratio is there to see: 9 of the 98 who test positive.